Imagine somebody asks how much money you want.
You probably have an answer. A salary. A portfolio. A house paid off. An amount that sounds reassuring when you say it aloud.
Now imagine they ask what an ordinary Wednesday would look like once you had it.
Would you work? Where would you live? Who would you see? What would you spend the morning doing? What would you stop doing?
The second answer is often less precise than the first.
We can become remarkably specific about a number while remaining vague about the life it is meant to support.
The obvious answer: more helps
Money pays for food, housing, education and care. It creates options when something goes wrong. It can let you leave a bad job, spend time with family or build something you believe in.
If your income does not cover your needs, being told to appreciate what you have can sound like advice from somebody whose bills are already paid.
There is nothing enlightened about financial insecurity. Wanting to improve your position is reasonable.
But as the position improves, another question emerges. Does the target describe a need, or has it become a way of keeping score?
A number can serve both purposes. It helps to know which one is driving the next decision.
Enough for what?
Enough to pay this month's bills is different from enough to survive a year without income. Enough to change careers is different from enough to stop earning altogether.
Then there is enough to feel successful. That one may have no reliable price.
You reach a milestone and meet somebody whose milestone is larger. The house that once represented arrival becomes the house you plan to leave. Your idea of normal quietly catches up with your income.
There may be good reasons for every change. A growing family needs space. An ageing parent needs support. A business needs investment.
The trouble begins when you cannot distinguish a changed responsibility from an upgraded expectation.
Instead of asking for one magic number, try naming the job each part of your money must do: sustain daily life, absorb shocks, create freedom, and support things you want to build or give.
A target becomes more useful when it has a purpose attached.
A life can be expensive without being chosen
Consider two imaginary households spending the same amount each month.
One pays for a home close to family, regular travel to see their children, and a workshop for a craft they love. The other carries payments on possessions bought mainly because they seemed like the next step.
The totals do not tell you which household is living well. Nor can a stranger decide which purchases matter.
But the totals conceal very different relationships between spending and purpose.
A useful spending review asks more than what can be cut. It asks which commitments earn their place in the life you actually want.
A cheaper life is not automatically a better life. A more expensive one is not automatically a fuller one.
What the research can—and cannot—tell us
In three studies published in 1993, psychologists Tim Kasser and Richard Ryan found that giving financial success greater importance relative to other aspirations was associated with poorer indicators of adjustment and well-being.[1]
This was evidence about the relative priority of goals. It did not establish that earning more makes people unhappy, that wealth is harmful, or that everyone should pursue the same lifestyle.
For our purposes, it offers a useful prompt: is financial progress supporting your other ambitions, or crowding them out?
The study cannot set your financial target. It can help you question what that target has come to represent.
Start with the Wednesday
Write a description of an ordinary day you would be pleased to repeat.
Keep it ordinary. Holidays are lovely, but most of a life happens between them.
Include where you live, what work remains, who you spend time with, and which activities give the day substance. Then identify the financial commitments required to support it.
Some may be substantial. Others may surprise you by costing little while requiring attention, courage or time.
Next, separate today's recurring costs from irregular obligations: repairs, travel, schooling, care and the other expenses that disappear from a tidy monthly budget but return in real life.
This exercise gives you a clearer spending picture. It does not establish how much invested capital you need, or whether you can safely stop working. Those questions involve uncertainty about returns, inflation, taxes, longevity and obligations.
Do not let an attractive number pretend to answer all of them.
Give your target a job
Turn the Wednesday exercise into a one-page brief. Separate four purposes:
- Daily life: the recurring cost of the home, food, transport and activities you actually want.
- Resilience: the resources and arrangements that help you cope with lost income, repairs or changing responsibilities.
- Freedom: the choice you want money to create, such as reducing your hours, changing careers or taking time to care for someone.
- Contribution: the work, people or projects you want to support beyond your own consumption.
Put an amount or a concrete description beside each. Where you do not know, write down the missing information rather than guessing.
This is a way to define the problem before trying to solve it. It is not a retirement calculation: converting those needs into an investment plan requires assumptions about your circumstances and future risks.
Then choose a review point. Revisit the brief when responsibilities change, or once a year. A target should be allowed to move when life changes. It deserves closer scrutiny when it moves only because somebody else has more.
Enough does not mean finished
You can define enough for your personal lifestyle and still want to build a business, become better at your work, or fund something valuable.
Ambition need not disappear when consumption stops expanding.
In fact, deciding what you no longer need to acquire may clarify what you want to accomplish.
The distinction is between wanting a larger life and requiring an ever-larger bill to believe you have one.
Before you move on
Finish these three sentences:
- I want money to make it possible for me to…
- I would be willing to stop upgrading…
- Even if my financial target were reached, I would still want to…
Your answers may not produce a precise number. They can give the number a direction.
Enough becomes useful when it changes a decision: the promotion you decline, the purchase you skip, the hours you reclaim, or the project you finally start. Until then, it is just another number to chase.
What would enough allow you to begin?
Sources
[1] Kasser, T., & Ryan, R. M. (1993). A dark side of the American dream: Correlates of financial success as a central life aspiration. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 65(2), 410–422. Study abstract.
The household examples are hypothetical. The exercises are GOOD QUESTION’s editorial framework.